SA/01 Self Aware
AI & Change Leadership Jun 7, 2026 3 min read

The First Draft Got Cheaper. Expertise Didn’t.

AI can make the first draft of your work cheaper. It cannot make your judgment automatic. That distinction matters when you have spent years proving your value by producing the thing everyone else needed: the strategy, the analysis, the plan…

Abstract technical line-art illustration of a circuit board, symbolizing the internal processing behind an integrity hangover after staying silent in a meeting.

AI can make the first draft of your work cheaper. It cannot make your judgment automatic.

That distinction matters when you have spent years proving your value by producing the thing everyone else needed: the strategy, the analysis, the plan that took hours of focus to get right. If a tool gives you a plausible draft in seconds, it can feel as though it has taken more than the task. It has taken the evidence you used to offer yourself that you belong.

Imagine a leader who asks AI to organize notes for a product strategy. The document comes back coherent and well structured. Instead of feeling relieved, he starts rewriting sentences that were already good enough. He changes the wording, moves paragraphs around, and spends time making the work look more like his.

That may be careful editing. It may also be an attempt to make his contribution visible again.

When effort becomes your proof of worth, removing effort can feel like removing worth. You may tell yourself you are protecting quality, while quietly restoring the friction that made you feel necessary.

Some caution is justified. A fluent draft can still be wrong. Using a tool without understanding the underlying work can leave you less able to spot errors, and some jobs may change or disappear rather than simply moving toward higher-level judgment. The people who benefit from the efficiency may not be the people whose work was made more efficient.

So “just review the output” is not enough. Review requires expertise. If you cannot recognize what is missing, a polished draft can make a bad decision look finished.

Consider a junior employee sharing an AI-assisted vendor proposal. The writing may be clear and the sequence logical, yet the proposal could overlook a technical constraint or a strained relationship with a key stakeholder. A leader who knows the people and the work may see risks the document does not show.

That knowledge is not magic. Leaders can misread a room, too. But it is part of the work: testing a draft against the realities it must survive, asking what has been omitted, and taking responsibility for the decision that follows.

The artifact and the expertise are not the same thing.

A first draft is visible. Judgment often is not. You can spend an afternoon writing a memo and feel productive; you can read the same memo in ten minutes, notice the assumption that would derail it, and feel as if you barely worked. The second task may matter more, but it is harder to point to.

That is where high performers can get caught. If you measure your value by how much you personally produce, you may reject a useful tool or make your team repeat work simply so your effort remains legible. You may also mistake a quiet contribution for no contribution at all.

The answer is not to surrender your craft. It is to keep it strong enough to evaluate what the tool produces. Use AI to help generate options, organize material, or get past a blank page when that serves the work. Then test the result: Is it accurate? Does it fit this situation? What does it leave out? Who carries the risk if it is wrong?

And notice when you are editing for quality—and when you are editing so the work feels like yours.

AI may change which parts of your expertise are visible. It does not relieve you of responsibility for the decisions made with its output. The uncomfortable question is whether you can still recognize your value when the evidence is no longer the hours you spent producing the first draft.

The newsletter

One honest leadership email.

A new essay and a question worth sitting with. Free. 13,000+ leaders read it.