SA/01 Self Aware
Leadership Loneliness Jun 14, 2026 3 min read

Leadership Feels Lonely. That Doesn’t Mean They’ve Rejected You

When you become a manager, people may become more careful around you.

Illustration of a single empty wooden chair, representing why promotion feels isolating when your old lunch table disappears.

When you become a manager, people may become more careful around you. It is easy to read that change as a verdict: they do not like me; they are talking about me; I have lost the people I used to be close to.

Sometimes a leader is being discussed. But the distance itself does not tell you what people are saying, or what they think of you.

Dani used to be part of the group chat. She knew the running jokes and the shared complaints about the people in charge. Then she became the manager. Now, when she joins a casual conversation, the jokes get a little more polite. Her team is responsive, but less relaxed around her.

She tries to bring back the old ease. She makes a self-deprecating comment about the expense software and lingers after a meeting to ask about everyone’s weekend. The replies are friendly enough, but brief.

She is looking for proof that the promotion did not cost her the belonging she had before.

That is an understandable desire. It can also become a bad measure of leadership. If your team’s comfort with you is the evidence you use to decide whether you are doing well, their ordinary privacy can start to feel like rejection. You may work harder to be liked when what the role asks of you is to be fair, clear, and trustworthy.

The relationship has changed because the job has changed. Dani still wants to advocate for her team, and she does. She fights for their budget and time off. But she also delivers feedback, makes decisions, and represents an organization whose choices affect their work. Her presence now carries authority, even when she is trying to be just another person in the conversation.

That does not make every awkward pause a sign of healthy boundaries. Persistent ridicule, exclusion from information people need to do their jobs, or concerns that have no safe route to reach you deserve attention. Privacy is not a shield for harmful conduct. If people are withholding work-related information or raising the same problem everywhere except with you, look at the pattern and ask what makes candor difficult.

But your team is allowed to have conversations you are not part of. They may need room to talk about a deadline, a client, or a decision you made. Sometimes the person with authority is part of the frustration. You cannot ask people to trust you and also require access to every unfiltered thought they have about you.

Dani needs honest feedback from her team. She does not need to be included in every private exchange to get it. Her responsibility is to make disagreement possible: invite specific concerns, respond without punishing the person who raised them, and follow through when the issue is real. Then pay attention to whether people can be direct with her about the work—not whether they act exactly as they did before she became their manager.

There is a reason leaders need relationships where they are not the person in charge. Dani vents to her own friends about her boss’s demands. She understands, from the other side, why someone might want space to speak freely.

Leadership can cost you some forms of closeness. Trying to win them back by performing approachability will not necessarily restore trust. Sometimes it only makes you more dependent on signs that you are still liked.

You do not have to choose between caring about your team and accepting that you are no longer simply one of them. You do have to stop treating inclusion as proof that you are leading well.

The newsletter

One honest leadership email.

A new essay and a question worth sitting with. Free. 13,000+ leaders read it.