Hard work can be easy to see when you are the one doing it. It is less reliable as a promotion strategy.
You can deliver consistently, take on extra responsibility, and still find that your manager does not have a clear picture of what you contributed—or how that contribution connects to the next role. The work happened. The story of the work may not have reached the people making the decision.
That is an uncomfortable distinction. We like to believe good work will speak for itself. But work does not speak. People notice it, interpret it, and decide what it means. Managers have limited attention, and promotion decisions involve judgment about what a role requires and who is ready to take it on.
This is why keeping track of your contribution can matter. In this episode, Nate Dinet describes the CARA method: Current Activities, Responsibilities, and Above and Beyond. The point is to record what you do, what you are responsible for, and where you have contributed beyond the expected work. Not to manufacture a case, but to make the work easier to discuss accurately.
A list of accomplishments is not a promotion. The next step is connecting your contribution to the role you want. What does that role require? Which responsibilities have you already taken on? What would your manager need to see to believe you are prepared for more?
Those questions make the conversation more concrete. They also help you find out whether you and your manager are working from the same expectations. A promotion discussion should not be the first time either of you tries to define what readiness means.
There is a reason many people avoid these conversations. Advocating for yourself can feel like bragging, especially if you believe strong work ought to be enough. But staying quiet does not make you more deserving. It may simply leave other people to fill in the blanks.
Still, “manage up” can become a convenient way to put the entire burden on the employee. You can make your impact clearer and ask direct questions. You cannot create an available role, change a budget, or guarantee that a decision-maker will be fair. Sometimes the organization cannot offer the next step. Sometimes the manager is not equipped to help you get there.
That matters. Self-advocacy can improve the conversation; it cannot control the outcome.
The useful question is not only, “Am I working hard enough?” It is also, “Does my manager understand what I contribute, what I want to do next, and what would need to be true for me to get there?” Ask for a candid conversation. Bring specific examples. Ask what gaps remain and when you will revisit the discussion.
Then pay attention to the answer—and to what happens afterward. A clear path is different from vague encouragement. If the expectations keep changing, or no real opportunity exists, that is information too.
Hard work still matters. But it is not a message sent automatically to the people deciding your future. You have to make the contribution legible, and the organization has to be willing to recognize it.
In this episode
Jason talks with Nate Dinet about manager relationships, career advocacy, the CARA method, and building an internal campaign for promotion.
- 00:00 — Introduction: career control and Nate Dinet’s journey
- 02:22 — The role managers can play in career growth
- 05:37 — Managers, training, and career support
- 10:53 — Understanding your manager’s motivations
- 14:25 — The CARA method
- 20:31 — Building an internal campaign for promotion
- 26:43 — Scaling without burnout
- 30:42 — Leading up and managing up
Resources: The Step Manager · Nate Dinet on LinkedIn · Book a one-on-one with Nate Dinet