SA/01 Self Aware
Mar 28, 2026 2 min read

The Ladder Wasn’t the Problem. The Scorecard Was.

A career can look successful from the outside and feel empty from the inside.

Former creative executive Rafael McMaster has described reaching substantial professional success—including work with high-profile clients and global brand campaigns—while feeling “emotionally bankrupt.” That phrase captures a difficult gap: the distance between what other people recognize and what you experience as meaningful.

It is tempting to explain that gap by saying he climbed the wrong ladder. Leave corporate work. Find a calling. Turn the pain into a mission.

That may be part of McMaster’s story. It is not a universal answer.

Corporate work can be meaningful. A depleted leader may be burned out, in the wrong role, or dealing with circumstances that have little to do with a conflict of values. Leaving a career does not automatically resolve any of those things.

The more useful question is what the scorecard has been rewarding.

Prestige, impressive clients, and recognition are visible. They tell you that your work has been valued by someone. They do not tell you whether you still value the work yourself. And because those markers often reward continued achievement, they can keep you moving long after the original reasons for moving have changed.

That is the danger—not ambition itself, but letting external measures answer a question they cannot answer for you.

McMaster’s account is a prompt to look closely at that difference. What earns praise in your role? What gives the work meaning to you? Where do those answers still meet, and where have they drifted apart?

You do not have to make an immediate, dramatic change. You do have to stop assuming the next milestone will settle the question. Sometimes the work needs to change. Sometimes the conditions around it do. Sometimes the first task is simply to admit that success and fulfillment are not interchangeable.

McMaster now leads Indivisible Arts, with a stated goal of empowering one million young people. His conversation also touches on art and a practice he calls “Mind Watching.” Those are elements of his path, not a prescription for every leader. A personal practice or a mission-driven organization may matter to one person without being the answer for another.

The leadership task is not to reject the scorecard. It is to notice when you have mistaken it for a measure of meaning—and to decide what you will do with that knowledge.

Explore: Rafael McMaster · Fundamental Life Tools: Self-Empowering Toolkit for Being · Indivisible Arts

The newsletter

One honest leadership email.

A new essay and a question worth sitting with. Free. 13,000+ leaders read it.