Employees can keep doing the job while quietly withdrawing from it.
The work gets done. People attend the meetings and answer the requests. But fewer concerns get raised, fewer ideas are offered, and no one seems eager to take ownership beyond what was assigned.
It is tempting to call that a motivation problem. Maybe the team needs a morale boost. A better perk. A free lunch or a ping-pong table.
Those things can be welcome. They cannot answer a more important question: when employees speak, does anything change?
Leaders sometimes ask for input after the meaningful decisions have already been made. They invite people to contribute, then treat the contribution as a courtesy rather than something that might alter the plan. The meeting says “we want your perspective.” The process says “the decision is already settled.”
People notice the difference.
You cannot demand ownership from people who have no influence over the work. And you cannot build trust by asking for candor while making disagreement costly. Employees may continue to comply. That is not the same as being bought in.
This does not explain every case of disengagement. Pay, workload, burnout, role fit, personal circumstances, and constraints beyond a manager’s control all matter. Co-creation will not repair unfair conditions or make an unsustainable job sustainable. But before deciding that an employee simply does not care, it is worth examining what the workplace has made safe—and worthwhile—for them to say.
That takes more than an invitation to share ideas. It takes curiosity instead of judgment, and a willingness to hear something inconvenient without punishing the person who said it. It also means being clear about where employees can shape a decision and where they cannot. An honest boundary is better than a false promise of influence.
In an episode of The Self Aware Leader, host Jason Rigby speaks with leadership coach and strategist Dave Garrison, author of The Buy-In Advantage, about humble leadership, emotional intelligence, co-creation, vulnerability, and trust. The episode includes three lines worth sitting with: “Judgment and curiosity cannot coexist”; “If you don’t have time to invest in people, get ready to spend it interviewing”; and “Leaders go last—except when it comes to vulnerability.”
These are not magic formulas. They point toward a harder practice: leaders have to make room for people to tell the truth, then show that their participation is real. Sometimes the answer will still be no. The explanation, and the way that no is handled, matter.
If you ask your team for input, look at the last decision they weighed in on. What changed because they spoke? If the answer is nothing, do not ask them to be more engaged before you examine what your invitation actually meant.
Resources: The Buy-In Advantage by Dave Garrison; GarrisonGrowth.com; connect with Dave on LinkedIn.
Listen to The Self Aware Leader at selfawarepodcast.com.